China is not Japan. Real estate, micro-credit and COVID scars are masking structural strengths. Unlike Japan, China is not recycling its trade surplus into foreign assets, while EV adoption reduces the income exported to pay for oil. Savings build productive capital, ultimately driving productivity, lower prices and rising real purchasing power. Meanwhile, China is emerging from a credit bust, while the US increasingly displays late-cycle excesses. The investment opportunity lies in recognising
Today's AI capex excess and Bitcoin's 'fixed money' delusion echo the 1847 financial crisis. Excessive capital spending crowds out other investments, straining consumers. Just as historical fixed-money policies caused havoc, today’s trade imbalances disrupt traditional interest rate mechanics. When trading partners refuse to recycle surpluses into US debt, they buy gold instead. High rates only work by lowering domestic prices to settle trade, explaining modern tariff pushes.
War embargoes trigger a recurring cycle: supply shocks drive price spikes, speculation surges, trade routes shift, and liquidity tightens. The Civil War cotton crisis mirrors the 1970s oil shocks and today’s energy markets—featuring demand destruction, falling real incomes, and cost-push inflation. These booms end in crashes, as capital misallocation and banking stress unwind the speculative excess.
In the 1820s, post-Napoleonic UK cut gilt coupons. Investors, denied real yield, chased returns in speculative ventures, funding dubious projects. Gilt demand collapsed, causing banking instability; the Bank of England injected liquidity. Today's parallel: US yield repression fuels risk-taking, lower-quality credit, Fed monetization. Gundlach warns a Treasury coupon cut could repeat this: yield-seeking bubble, credit deterioration, contraction. Lesson: cheat on debt, get a bubble, then a bust.
The Minsky clean-up is not unique to today or the US. A similar dynamic occurred in the UK in 1825 after post-war debt led to changes in gilt coupons. Today’s SPAC boom echoes past speculative excesses. As always, the cycle turns when credit tightens. Cutting gilt coupons has two key effects: it shifts relative yields and disrupts credit markets.